Most conventional toothpastes are packed with synthetic dyes, sulfates, and fluoride compounds your mouth really doesn't need. This all-natural organic whitening toothpaste from Butter Me Up Organics takes a different approach — a clean, carefully crafted blend of baking soda, sea salt, calcium, coconut oil, and essential oils that leaves your teeth feeling genuinely polished and your mouth truly fresh. Packaged in a reusable 2 oz. glass jar, it's a thoughtful gift for anyone making the switch to a cleaner daily routine.
⚠️ Please note: This toothpaste is naturally salty due to the sea salt and baking soda content. Separation in the product is normal.
⚠️ This product has not been evaluated by the FDA. It is not intended to diagnose, treat, cure, or prevent any disease, and does not replace the advice of a dental or medical professional.
Ready to make the switch to a cleaner smile? Add the Butter Me Up Organics Natural Whitening Toothpaste to your cart today — your teeth, gums, and the planet will thank you. 🌍🦷
Our efforts to reduce our CO2 emissions generated by the sending of your orders mean that today Clozist is Carbon Positive on its shipments.
With the help of Greenspark we voluntarily offset 7kg of CO2 and remove 2 plastic bottles from the oceans with each order at no extra cost to you.
Why 7kgs (15.43 lb)?
We took the average Carbon Emission of a 2lb package ground sent from NYC to LA and multiply that number by 4.
Why 2 bottles?
Millions of plastic bottles pollute our oceans every year, two standard bottles are a daily recommended water intake. We're committed to cleaning them up.
Butter Me Up Organics was born in 2008 from a simple but powerful moment of frustration. After spending $25 on a body butter in Pasadena, founder Jillian thought — I can make this better myself. So she did.
What followed was three years of deep research into ingredients, sourcing, safety, and certifications. Every recipe is entirely her own, crafted not for cost efficiency but for maximum therapeutic benefit. Each product is still handmade today — no synthetic ingredients, no artificial fragrances, no dyes. Just pure, purposeful formulas designed to actually work.
Packaging matters too. While others pushed for plastic, Jillian chose glass, tin, and paper — because using the most thoughtfully sourced ingredients in a plastic container felt like a contradiction she couldn't live with. Every label is printed with soy ink on recycled paper, and every shipment uses recycled packing materials.
The results speak for themselves. Customers have shared photos of children's eczema clearing the same day, and teenage acne disappearing after years of struggle. Those moments are why Butter Me Up exists.
Higher standards mean thinner margins — and Jillian is perfectly at peace with that. Because she knows what's in every jar, and she knows it's the best available.
Thank you for supporting the work we do. It means everything. 🤍
Orders are usually dispatched within 2-3 business days.
The shipping rate is calculated and displayed at checkout. Free shipping is available for orders over $49.00 for Shakers members of our reward program, and with no minimum, for Makers members (We can't offer free shipping when the lowest shipping cost exceeds $10).
Shipment confirmation and order tracking:
Once your order is fulfilled, you receive a tracking number to follow your package by email. Allow 24-48 hours for the carrier to update the tracking number in its system.
We might ship your order in more than 1 package. In that case, you receive a tracking number for each shipment.
Your order might be delayed in case we experience a high volume of orders. If your order fulfillment is delayed, we will let you know by email asap.
Shop Local and Climate-Friendly
We connect you with a curated selection of local, climate-friendly products from American businesses.
